 The election may have shaken Washington, D.C., like a snow globe in the grip of a paint mixer, but the current Congress still has important business for the lame duck session. For anyone who cares about privacy in this age of surveillance, issue one has to be whether or not Congress will retain the promised fix to what so many call the “make everyone a spy” provision in the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). This story goes back to April, when the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence slipped into the reauthorization of FISA Section 702 (which authorizes foreign intelligence) a measure to allow the government to secretly enlist almost every kind of U.S. business to spy on their customers. In response to the outcry, carveouts were made that exempted coffee shops, hotels, and a few other business categories. But most businesses – ranging from gyms to dentists’ offices, to commercial landlords with tenants that could include political campaigns or journalists – are required to turn over their customers’ communications that run on ordinary Wi-Fi systems. It is widely believed that this legislation was aimed at cloud computing facilities, which were not previously covered by the relevant law. When the Senate took up reauthorization of Section 702, Intelligence Committee Chairman Mark Warner (D-VA) admitted to his colleagues that the new measure was overbroad, and that he would craft new legislation to fix it. Sen. Warner kept his word and crafted legislation to narrow the provision. Although the nature of this fix is classified, it is widely believed to limit this new surveillance power to cloud computing facilities. The House Intelligence Committee, however, did not adopt that fix. We hear that behind-the-scenes negotiations are taking place, but we cannot report exactly who might be blocking it or why. Suffice it to say that it is far from clear that Congress will ultimately adopt Sen. Warner’s fix. PPSA calls on Speaker Mike Johnson and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell to make it clear that the NDAA will include a provision to narrow the scope of this extreme provision. We must not give the FBI and other government agencies warrantless access to practically all communications that run through any kind of equipment operated by almost any kind of business. Allowing the current law to remain unfixed and unreformed would be a terrible punch in the gut to the American people and the new Congress. The 119th Congress has many surveillance debates scheduled, including one over the reauthorization of Section 702 itself in 2026 – which passed the House with the breaking of a tie vote. It would be a mistake to saddle the new Republican majority and the incoming Trump administration with a broken promise. Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed