 Today, Hungary is ostensibly free, a democratic state in a union of democratic states. But something is rotten in Budapest. Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has been steadily fashioning a monoculture since his return to power 15 years ago, running afoul of European Union policies and democratic norms along the way. The most recent infraction is multifaceted, and it involves the use of facial recognition to target peaceful protesters for criminal prosecution. In March, Orbán’s subservient parliament railroaded the opposition and banned public gatherings of gay rights activists. With the stroke of a pen, Pride gatherings and related pro-gay rights protests were suddenly illegal. A month later, these crackdowns were enshrined in the country’s constitution (showing why America’s founders were wise to foresee the necessity in making the U.S. Constitution so notoriously difficult to amend). As in Putin’s Russia, the justification for this crackdown is that it’s necessary to protect children from “sexual propaganda” – even though we are talking about peaceful protests conducted by adults in city centers. However you feel about Pride parades, most Hungary watchers believe the prime minister needs to whip up a cultural scapegoat to rally his base in advance of next year’s elections. Hungary represents a turning point in the rise of the modern surveillance state in a developed country. Beyond the infringement of basic rights, it includes a chilling new embrace of facial recognition technology – specifically, to identify Pride participants (now officially designated as criminals) or likewise pick out faces from among the tens of thousands who are sure to illegally protest these new measures. At the moment, the punishment for such unconstitutional behavior is a fine of up to €500. Organizers, however, can be imprisoned for up to a year. But can even more draconian punishments be far behind? If you’re wondering how Hungary’s democratic partners in the European Union are reacting to all of this, the answer is not well. And it’s also raising important questions about the efficacy of the EU’s AI regulations in general (a debate about loopholes and guardrails that merits a separate discussion). For now, though, Americans should take in a cautionary warning from Hungary’s use of facial recognition software. Future uses of the technology here could target leaders of a MAGA or a Black Lives Matter protest. Facial recognition scans can pinpoint individuals, spotting the face in a crowd. It gives regimes the ability to come back later to arrest and persecute on a scale only Orwell could have conceived. All of this is enhanced by the unholy combination of data analytics, advanced algorithms, unprecedented computing power, and now generative AI. The uncomfortable truth of the modern era is inescapable: The development and deployment of modern surveillance has gone hand in hand with modern authoritarianism, from Russia to China and Iran. Just imagine what might have happened if J. Edgar Hoover had access to facial recognition tech and AI. We imagine it would have looked like Orbán’s dystopian democracy. Budapest Pride is not backing down, celebrating its 30th anniversary in a public demonstration in June. The world will be watching to see how this technology is used. Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed