How the FBI Turns Banks into Spies

The Horror … the Horror … of Federal Financial Surveillance Revealed by U.S. House Report

​In a previous blog, we reported on the use of “Suspicious Activity Reports” mandated by the Bank Secrecy Act to spy on politically disfavored groups.
 
We also reported that the government uses these reports to force banks to close the accounts of groups ranging from a trade association to pawn shops, firearms dealers, and a former First Lady. Debanking is an easy way to silence or intimidate people and organizations.
 
Now, thanks to a recent report from the House Judiciary Committee and its Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government, it is clear that this misuse of this law is even more expansive and worse than we suspected.
 
Congress enacted the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) to require banks to report to the government suspicious transactions by customers that might indicate that they are linked to terrorism, human trafficking, or drug dealing. The House report reveals that the FBI “has turned this framework on its head” by issuing “requests” – authorized by no law – to demand banks spy on targeted people or organizations. In 48,000 pages of documents, House investigators could confirm only one financial institution requested legal process from the FBI for the information it was seeking. “All too often,” House investigators wrote, “the FBI appeared to receive no pushback.” They concluded:
 
“In sum, the FBI has turned this framework on its head and contravened the Fourth Amendment’s requirement of particularity and probable cause.”
 
While the FBI had an obligation to seek out those who beat police officers and smashed the doors and windows of the Capitol on Jan. 6, it coordinated with the U.S. Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) to encourage financial institutions across the country to scour their data and file Suspicious Activity Reports on Americans without any clear criminal nexus. As we reported before, Americans were targeted for going to certain stores, like Dick’s Sporting Goods or a Bass Pro Shop.
 
A Bank Secrecy Act Advisory Group, meant to serve as an advisory body to the Treasury Department, has become a secret service unto itself. House investigators report that this advisory group “is also a tool for federal law enforcement and financial institutions to monitor the private, financial data of American citizens.”
 
The scale of warrantless surveillance under this authority is immense. In 2023, some 25,000 federal, state, and local officials had warrantless access to data acquired under this law. In 2023, government officials ran more than 3.3 million searches of a FinCEN Query program of these reports. FinCEN reports that “472 federal, state, and local law enforcement, regulatory, and national security agencies have access to BSA reports …”
 
And this is just one federal program monitoring Americans financial lives, which is a way of monitoring our personal, romantic, political, and religious lives as well. Reforming the Bank Secrecy Act should be at the top of the agenda for the incoming Trump Administration and the 119th Congress.

DONATE & HELP US PROTECT YOUR PRIVACY RIGHTS