Cameras on Trash Trucks, Buses, and in Robotaxis – Everywhere In the 1998 dramedy The Truman Show, the title character (played by Jim Carrey) is the unwitting star of a reality TV show he doesn’t know exists. When Truman makes funny faces in front of the mirrored medicine cabinet, a hidden camera installed behind his pill bottles captures his every silly expression. When he sings to himself in the car, a camera and microphone inside the dashboard radio catch his performance. Truman is tracked by cameras in streetlights, vending machines, traffic signs, and even the ring his father gave him. The movie follows Truman Burbank as it gradually dawns on him that he has been constantly surveilled all his life, and that his mother, wife, and best friend are all actors, playing roles in a reality show that millions of people watch. Almost thirty years later, Americans are coming to the dispiriting realization that we are all Truman now, reality TV stars tracked by cameras everywhere. PPSA has reported on the ubiquity of Ring doorbell cameras and the national network of Flock Safety cameras and other automated license-plate readers (ALPRs). As in The Truman Show, there is so much more. If you live in a city where robotaxis operated by companies such as Waymo, Zoox, and Tesla are available, the driverless cars you ride in have interior cameras and sensors watching you. Aarian Marshall of Wired reports that questions remain about how companies collect, retain, and use passenger data. Then there are trash trucks. An Alabama-based company, City Detect, has contracts to install AI-equipped cameras on sanitation trucks to capture and analyze images of homes and lawns, flagging possible code violations involving tall grass, litter, graffiti, and more serious problems. The system assigns a “Blight Score” to properties. City Detect says it has flagged 6 million violations nationwide, leading to “courtesy notices” informing residents that an inspector might come to their homes and issue a citation. One resident of a low-income neighborhood in Dallas told a local television news show that he felt the system was “trying to flush us out.” Cameras are also being installed on city buses in Los Angeles to catch cars illegally parked in bus lanes, and on the sides of school buses in Austin to detect cars that fail to stop when school buses are unloading children. Each of these uses has a justification. Communities have a right to keep neighborhoods clean and orderly. Buses need clear lanes to make mass transit work. Robotaxi companies need to know if passengers are vandalizing a vehicle or doing something dangerous. And children need to be protected from drivers who whip around stopped school buses. The problem is that cameras can easily be repurposed. The same cameras that watch for tall grass, parked cars, drunk passengers, and dangerous drivers can also watch the rest of us – adding another layer of public surveillance to that created by Flock and other ALPRs. As a nation, we are creating a system of ubiquitous surveillance, sometimes without knowing who is watching and why. When St. Lucie County, Florida, ordered Flock cameras removed from county roads, officials discovered 11 cameras with no permits, publicly identified owners, or obvious purpose. Who installed those 11 road cameras? Who has access to their data? Why the secret surveillance? In the movie, after Truman learns what is happening to him, he asks the show’s creator, “Was nothing real?” “You were real,” replies the creator, played by Ed Harris. “That’s what made you so good to watch.” Comments are closed.
|
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed