Why Are House Intel Republicans Clinging to the “Make Everyone a Spy” Law?

“Why are House Intelligence Committee Republicans so happy to carry water for the Biden Administration?” This was a question put to us by an incredulous Republican politician. He added: “Why is it that Democrats in the Senate are doing a better job of protecting privacy from the administration and the intelligence community than House Republicans?”
 
Here is what he was getting at: in April, the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence slipped into the reauthorization of Section 702 a measure that would allow the government to potentially enlist almost every kind of business to warrantlessly spy on any American’s communications contained in any kind of electronic communications equipment. Now law, this measure could force ordinary businesses – from gyms to dentists’ offices, to commercial landlords with tenants that could include political campaigns or journalists – to turn over their customers’ communications that run on ordinary systems, such as WiFi.
 
For obvious reasons, this came to be known as the new “Make Everyone a Spy” law.
 
In April, when the Senate prepared to reauthorize FISA Section 702, which authorizes surveillance of foreign targets located abroad, Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) won the votes of his colleagues by frankly admitting that the House language “could have been drafted better.” He promised that the Senate Intelligence Committee would fix it with a narrower definition of covered “electronic communications service providers.”
 
“The idea that you draw it so broad, and then try to exclude things, well, you’re never going to be able to figure out all the possible exceptions,” Warner said in an interview.
 
True to his word, Sen. Warner led his committee to include language in the Intelligence Authorization Act that narrows the definition of a covered electronic communications service provider. The actual language of the amendment, based on an opinion by the secret FISA Court, is classified. But the Warner fix is widely believed by the media to narrow this law to cover cloud computing centers, which did not exist when the governing law, the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, was enacted in 1986 and amended more than 15 years ago. (Under current law, communication companies, like Google and Verizon, are already required to cooperate with the government on data searches for foreign threats.)
 
That fix, however, fails to impress Rep. Mike Turner (R-Ohio) and other leading Members of the House Intelligence Committee. They are avoiding Sen. Warner’s legislation and seem determined to perpetuate the expansive definition of “Make Everyone a Spy” in the House version of the Intelligence Authorization Act.
 
House insiders tell us that it is now up to Speaker Johnson and reform-minded Republicans to ensure that the Warner fix is made in the House legislation. Absent that, civil liberties champions will have to cross our fingers and hope that the fix will be made in a House-Senate conference committee.
​