Project for Privacy and Surveillance Accountability (PPSA)
  • Issues
  • Solutions
  • SCORECARD
    • Congressional Scorecard Rubric
  • News
  • About
  • TAKE ACTION
    • Section 702 Reform
    • PRESS Act
    • DONATE
  • Issues
  • Solutions
  • SCORECARD
    • Congressional Scorecard Rubric
  • News
  • About
  • TAKE ACTION
    • Section 702 Reform
    • PRESS Act
    • DONATE

 NEWS & UPDATES

FBI, State Deem FOIA’s Clear Classification Request to be “Vague”

4/19/2021

 
In September, 2020, PPSA filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request with the CIA, FBI, NSA, ODNI, Department of Justice, State Department, and National Archives and Records Administration. We asked them to simply reveal any references to Executive Order 13526 in their records since its adoption in 2009.

This order prohibits classification of material in order to “conceal violations of law, inefficiency, or administrative error” or to “prevent embarrassment to a person, organization, or agency.” It also obligates each agency to create internal procedures to challenge improper classification decisions.

While the CIA and ODNI stated that they had begun their searches pursuant to our FOIA request, the FBI and State Department have rejected identical requests, claiming they were “too vague.” This is despite the fact that our requests are bolstered by federal precedent compelling agency responses to FOIA requests for all documents mentioning specific search terms. As reviewing courts have explained, such requests for simple keyword searches leave "virtually no guesswork" about what documents will be responsive to the request.

Every American knows the simple “CTRL F” function on our computer keyboards to search for keywords. The FBI and State Department nevertheless maintain our request to be too “vague” to manage such a simple search. The inconsistency is striking when compared with the other agencies that did not plead “vagueness.”

As of now, both the FBI and the State Department have rejected our appeals, exhausting possible administrative remedies and freeing PPSA to enforce those agencies’ statutory disclosure duties in federal court.

Concerns continue to mount over the quantity of classified materials and the possible circumvention of federal law. So troubling was this trend that even as far back as 1989, former Solicitor General for Richard Nixon, Erwin Griswold, who argued the Pentagon Papers case on behalf of the government, wrote: “[I]t quickly becomes apparent to any person who has considerable experience with classified material that there is massive overclassification and that the principal concern of the classifiers is not with national security, but rather with governmental embarrassment of one sort or another.”

More recently, a 2011 report to the President by the Information Security Oversight Office, as required by EO 13526, showed that even after the order’s passage, derivative classification activity continued to skyrocket, quadrupling in four recent years.
Like a bad housekeeper sweeping dirt under the rug, the bureaucracy seems to be latching on to derivative classification as the place to evade accountability. PPSA will continue to fight for transparency and accountability in government surveillance.

Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    2022 Year In Review
    2023 Year In Review
    2024 Year In Review
    Analysis
    Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    Call To Action
    Congress
    Congressional Hearings
    Congressional Unmasking
    Court Appeals
    Court Hearings
    Court Rulings
    Digital Privacy
    Domestic Surveillance
    Facial Recognition
    FISA
    FISA Reform
    FOIA Requests
    Foreign Surveillance
    Fourth Amendment
    Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act
    Government Surveillance
    Government Surveillance Reform Act (GSRA)
    Insights
    In The Media
    Lawsuits
    Legal
    Legislation
    Letters To Congress
    NDO Fairness Act
    News
    Opinion
    Podcast
    PPSA Amicus Briefs
    Private Data Brokers
    Protect Liberty Act (PLEWSA)
    Saving Privacy Act
    SCOTUS
    SCOTUS Rulings
    Section 702
    Spyware
    Stingrays
    Surveillance Issues
    Surveillance Technology
    The GSRA
    The SAFE Act
    Warrantless Searches
    Watching The Watchers

    RSS Feed

FOLLOW PPSA: 
© COPYRIGHT 2024. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. | PRIVACY STATEMENT
Photo from coffee-rank