Project for Privacy and Surveillance Accountability (PPSA)
  • Issues
  • Solutions
  • SCORECARD
    • Congressional Scorecard Rubric
  • News
  • About
  • TAKE ACTION
    • Section 702 Reform
    • PRESS Act
    • DONATE
  • Issues
  • Solutions
  • SCORECARD
    • Congressional Scorecard Rubric
  • News
  • About
  • TAKE ACTION
    • Section 702 Reform
    • PRESS Act
    • DONATE

 NEWS & UPDATES

Keyword Searches and the Problem of “Particularity”

10/5/2021

 
Picture
The Fourth Amendment requires that a probable cause warrant be issued “particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.” But how does one define particularity in the age of digital networks and the cloud?
 
This question acquires fresh urgency after Thomas Brewster of Forbes noticed a court document accidentally unsealed by the Department of Justice. The document showed that the government had asked Google to divulge the identities of anyone who had searched for the name, phone number and address of a sex trafficking victim, as well as her mother’s name, over a 16-day span. Google was also directed to provide Google accounts and IP addresses of those who made these searches.
 
Because such orders are kept under seal, there is no way to know how common they are. One such order made public was in 2020 for any individual who searched for the address of an arson victim in the government’s racketeering case against singer R. Kelly. Two others involved a fraud case in Minnesota and a serial bomber in Austin. 
 
In the case of the sex-trafficked victim, the keyword search – while limited to two people and a small number of searches – also included a request for CookieIDs. These are identifiers that can be used to group together every search from a particular device over a given duration. This gives law enforcement an ability to widen its view, and to see every website the owner of that device has visited.
 
In such a world, unimagined by the Founders, where does particularity end? A computer or other digital device certainly qualifies as a particular object, but its reach is global, allowing for a deep and pervasive search of a person’s interests, beliefs and contacts.
 
To be sure, law enforcement needs tools to catch sex traffickers or bombers. But by their very nature, keyword searches could easily become dragnets in which no particular person or group is the target. Instead, a keyword search can act like a fishing trawler dragging its net along the ocean floor – exactly the kind of open-ended investigation the Founders feared and explicitly forbade.
 
The worst aspect of this practice is that these warrants are executed in secret.
 
PPSA urges the Department of Justice to annually release the number of warrants for keyword searches it has sought and obtained. We ask Attorney General Merrick Garland to issue a policy directive, beyond those currently in place to protect journalists, that would define the scope of keyword searches within precise and necessary limits.
 
States should also codify these standards as well for state and urban police departments.

Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    2022 Year In Review
    2023 Year In Review
    2024 Year In Review
    Analysis
    Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    Call To Action
    Congress
    Congressional Hearings
    Congressional Unmasking
    Court Appeals
    Court Hearings
    Court Rulings
    Digital Privacy
    Domestic Surveillance
    Facial Recognition
    FISA
    FISA Reform
    FOIA Requests
    Foreign Surveillance
    Fourth Amendment
    Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act
    Government Surveillance
    Government Surveillance Reform Act (GSRA)
    Insights
    In The Media
    Lawsuits
    Legal
    Legislation
    Letters To Congress
    NDO Fairness Act
    News
    Opinion
    Podcast
    PPSA Amicus Briefs
    Private Data Brokers
    Protect Liberty Act (PLEWSA)
    Saving Privacy Act
    SCOTUS
    SCOTUS Rulings
    Section 702
    Spyware
    Stingrays
    Surveillance Issues
    Surveillance Technology
    The GSRA
    The SAFE Act
    Warrantless Searches
    Watching The Watchers

    RSS Feed

FOLLOW PPSA: 
© COPYRIGHT 2024. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. | PRIVACY STATEMENT
Photo from coffee-rank